Tracker money are very best – unless you are investing in Britain

Analysis problems the notion that tracker funds run by computer systems constantly generate greater functionality than a human

  Photograph: AP

Money run by human stock-pickers fail to beat people that blindly stick to the stock marketplace – with the exception of money that invest in British shares.

This is the conclusion of in depth analysis into the performance of “active” and “passive” money by S&ampP Dow Jones Indices.

Since 2009 almost nine in ten actively managed funds that invest in British shares have completed what they set out to achieve by beating the overall performance of the stock market place as a total, the report discovered.

Just 14pc of the 627 funds that invest in British shares have underperformed the S&ampP’s United Kingdom benchmark index over the previous five years. The rest – a total of 533 money – have managed to beat the index.

But this record contrasted strongly with the efficiency of money that invest in shares from other parts of the planet.

Relevant Posts

  • Four exciting investments savers have missed

    03 Aug 2014

  • The loyal traders who shell out three instances the going price for tracker money

    24 Jun 2014

  • Twelve of the world’s best tracker money

    25 Feb 2014

  • Buffett’s a fan: must you switch to a tracker?

    12 Could 2014

  • 500,000 fund traders failed by trackers

    19 Jan 2014

The bulk of international money, two in three, have underperformed the related index because 2009, even though 54pc of European and 51pc US funds failed to beat their respective indices.

Funds that invest in less mature economies, the so-called emerging markets, also disappointed. The research identified that 67pc of these money underperformed.

Fund sector

Percentage that beat S&ampP index over 5 many years

Percentage that beat S&ampP index above 3 many years

Percentage that beat S&ampP index above a single year

Uk funds




European money (excluding United kingdom)




International money




US funds




Emerging industry money




Supply: S&ampP Dow Jones Indices

The authors of the report place the outperformance of United kingdom funds down to the fact that the five greatest British shares in the FTSE one hundred, HSBC, BP, Royal Dutch Shell, GlaxoSmithKline and British American Tobacco, make up more than 20pc of the index.

A tracker fund, which aims to replicate the FTSE 100’s functionality, has hold the same huge weightings in these shares.

An active fund manager, nevertheless, is unlikely to have this kind of massive exposure – and shares in smaller firms have tended to outperform in latest many years.

Tracker funds, which are run by personal computers rather than human beings, have been in existence because the Seventies, but investors have warmed to them increasingly in recent many years, partly since of adverse publicity about the fees on lively funds.

In excess of the past 3 many years an huge £30bn of British savings has flooded into these funds, which now entice £1 in each £10 of investors’ cash.

Numerous savers have grow to be disillusioned with fund managers as only a select couple of tend to carry out regularly year following yr.

Like our Facebook ‘Money’ page at

Investment suggestions every week by e mail – signal up right here